With
the recent developments of Johnny Manziel and NCAA Conference Commissioners’
calling for changes in how the NCAA does business, intercollegiate athletics
are under fire again. In the age
of 24 hours news and social media student-athletes from youth sports to college
are under more scrutiny than ever.
Manziel was the first
freshman to win the Heisman Trophy in 2012 and since winning the award he has
been in the news for all the wrong reasons. Excessive drinking, lashing out on Twitter, being sent home
from the Manning’s Passing Camp, kicked out of a fraternity party at Univ. of
Texas, and most recently being investigated for selling his autograph in
January, which would be a NCAA violation.
He has become the most recent case study of how imperative personal
development is while pursuing and achieving athletic success.
|
2012 Heisman Trophy Winner Johnny Manziel. |
Wright
Thompson of ESPN Magazine recent article
“The trouble with Johnny” illustrates more of how his family enabled him more
than teach him valuable lessons growing up. Manziel is an example of how personal development is
critical for all of us, not excluding raising a child that is gifted
athletically. This is not an indictment
on his character or his parents, but shows how easily personal development can
come at the cost of pursuing athletic achievement and the success that comes
with it. Parents, youth coaches,
and administrators need to find as many teachable moments through athletics. This does not have to come at the cost
of developing their athletic skills and being competitive. What tends to happen is that parents
and coaches get caught up in the hype of athletic achievement. As Thompson put it referring to Johnny Manziel, “People
on the outside see only the final collapse: the drunken photo, the fight
outside a bar, the angry tweet. They never see the slow decay, because that
happens in private.”
|
St. Francis Academy Baltimore, MD. |
Young athletes should have coaches
and administrators who are as concerned about the impact they leave on young
people’s lives. How many athletes
can look back and say that playing for a coach made them a better person, some
can and some can’t. The
influential figures in a young athletes life see the signs, yet in many
instances enable the behavior instead of addressing it head on. Unfortunately some coaches take up the
profession for the wrong reasons. They
see it as an opportunity to profit or live their dreams vicariously through
young boys and girls or self-gratification. Others have a passion for the respective sport and view
coaching as an opportunity to give back and teach valuable lessons. I recently visited St. Francis Academy
in inner city Baltimore, MD during an Under Armour commercial shoot. I was able to hear stories of how the
coaches, chaplain, and staff have used football the change young men’s lives. One player on the team is getting a
scholarship to an Ivy League school.
The support system at St. Francis is determined to use football to
change lives. Regardless of the
social economic conditions this should be the goal for all coaches dealing with
our youth.
Sports can breed many positive
character traits such as teamwork, discipline, interacting with authority, leadership,
success, dealing with setbacks, interpersonal skills and many more. Also, it can breed entitlement,
selfishness, laziness, and disrespect.
Whichever side of the pendulum an individual is on it is rooted in the
foundation laid by parents and coaches at a very young age. In Jim Loehr’s book The Only Way To Win, a prominent Division I college coach
is quoted saying, “Parents teach values, church teach values, I’m paid to coach
and win. Don’t expect me to cover
that ground as well.” Another
coach was quoted, “My greatest stress is having to coach players I don’t
respect, whose character are seriously broken and flawed. I can’t boot them from the team because
I can’t win without them. I end up
helping them become superstars. I hate myself for leading people I don’t
respect to victory.” These feelings
very common at the college level because young men and women were not taught
the values in their early development.
A college coach with pressure to win inherits them with these issues and
probably looked over them in the recruiting process. Texas A&M Coach Kevin Sumlin is dealing with a multitude
of issues with Manziel, who is a rising redshirt sophomore with a personal
assistant who dropped out of school for the position. Johnny’s family compensates the
personal assistant and security guards when he is at certain functions.
|
Robert Griffin III, Russell Wilson, and Andrew Luck |
The 2012 NFL football season saw
Robert Griffin III, Andrew Luck, and Russell Wilson lead their teams to
playoffs as rookies. They
demonstrated leadership and maturity that was infectious to their respective
teams. On the other hand, Cam Newton
entered the 2011 season with questions about his maturity and leadership and
showed poor body language when things did not go his way. These are examples of how differently
the accolades and recognition at a young age were handled. It does not make Newton a bad person,
but shows the difference in maturity and intangibles that the other three
quarterbacks possess. Manziel
unprecedented success as a freshman quarterback probably didn’t change him,
just exposed the traits that his parents did not focus on during his
upbringing.
My concern is through athletics
what kinds of people are being developed.
Well rounded, disciplined, respectful ones or entitled, selfish, and
narcissistic. It is up to parents
and youth coaches to realize the importance of using sports as a teaching
tool. There is nothing wrong
with putting the time and effort to maximize athletic ability. It should not come at the cost of their
personal development.
Relationships and experiences through athletics will last a lifetime. Those experiences can be a foundation
of our future leaders who set a positive example.